I feel bad putting something in last place, but it’s got to happen.
Two for the price of none! It’s a twofer (oh god) this time, since I thought I didn’t have much to say. Turns out I did.
12) No One’s First, and You’re Next (2009)
It isn’t bad, it just isn’t as good. The EP’s got some great songs, but something’s got to fill the last spot.
Guilty Cocker Spaniels is stuck in my head probably more than any other song, it’s one of my favourite of their more happy/upbeat sounding songs (second to Missed the Boat). Standout lyrics: “I drew a blank, we put it in a frame”.
The Whale Song is one of the best jammy songs they’ve done. It’s not a typical MM song (is that even a thing), but it’s really top notch. It’s nice to see the cool guitar sounds from this song re-appear on the latest album. The two sets of lyrics on top of eacher eventually meeting up is pretty cool.
People seem to love King Rat, I think it’s pretty good. Autumn Beds and I’ve got it all (most) are both really standout tracks.
It’s a strange EP in that every time I listen to a song, I like it a lot, but there’s nothing that really keeps me coming back.
11) We Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank (2007)
I actually love this album, but I love the other ones more.
March into the Sea, Parting of the Sensory, Missed the Boat and Spitting Venom are some of the best “new” Modest Mouse songs. Johnny Marr is absolutely brilliant in The Smiths, and he shines here too. Just for the fact that he was a part makes me want to rank this higher.
March into the sea was a song I didn’t quite like at first, but I think it’s one of the best “new” MM songs. It’s got the classic loud/angry and soft/pretty dynamic that MM is so good at. The “I’ll be beating my hearts record for speeding” bit is perfect.
Parting of the Sensory is another of their best. I’m still certainly uncertain whether “carbon’s anniversary” is a really cheesy pun on carbon dating. Musically the whole song is pretty dark sounding which works well leading up the spectacular ending. “A lifelong walk to the same exact spot” really ties in with “Someday you will die, and somehow something’s gonna steal your carbon”.
Missed the Boat is one of my favourite MM songs, especially the “tiny curtains open…” section. I’m still not sure what to take from the lyrics, but I think that’s the point. It’s a bit of a glass half full/emty situation. For whatever reason it’s my essential pre-exam song (along with Jupiter, Bringer of Jollity from Gustav Holst’s Planets). No idea why.
Those are the stand outs for me, on with the rest.
They seemed to throw the three big poppy ones, tracks 2, 3 and 4 together. They’re great songs, just different. I always liked “You told me about nowhere, well it sounds like some place I’d like to go”. Interesting that the big single, Dashboard, shares it’s main idea with Float On, the big single from Good News. “The dashboard melted, but we still had radio”, “the car was on blocks, but I was already where I want”, both ring true with “A fake Jamaican took every last dime with that scam, It was worth it just to learn some slight of hand”.
While the tracks don’t shine on their own as much, the middle half of this album works very well when you listen to it all together. It always seemed like one long song to me. We’ve Got Everything and Fly Trapped In A jar are both vaguely connected (which is just noticed now), with “Well, first off, Gary got drunk, fell asleep in his car ’til about noon” and “We’ve tried everything, like trial by fire” , followed by “First off, Gary was on trial and drunk before we’d left bed” in the next song. I always liked “Well, I hadn’t noticed, but the people really noticed that they really didn’t want us around. So not a single one of us will ever leave town”. Education is pretty great. In general, the MM fan base hates Steam Eugenius, which never would have occurred to me. Not the best, not the worst. It ties in well with the stasis stuff that crops up all around the album.
In a very un-Modest Mouse fashion (see: every other album), the ending is a bit lacklustre. If the album ended with spitting venom, I think the whole thing would work a bit better. That’s not to say People… and Invisible aren’t any good, but Spitting Venom is just a perfect way to end.
Overall, We Were Dead is certainly different, but it’s a great album.